I started kayaking about 18 years ago. Over those years I have had a fun
hobby of buying used kayaks, refurbishing them as necessary, paddling
them for some time, and then selling to try the next boat. I have
paddled many different sea kayaks from manufacturers such as North
Shore (before the Valley takeover), Mariner, Sterling, NDK/SKUK,
Valley, Necky, P&H, Seaward, Current Designs, Boreal Design, etc.
No kayak is perfect
for any user nor for every purpose. For example, a very nimble and maneuverable kayak could be perfect for rock gardening, but will
likely be a poor choice for an expedition. Personally, I prefer a
skeg to a rudder, but if I were into expedition journeys and camping
along the way, I would opt for a rudder. The paddler’s skill level
is also a crucial factor. For my skill level and choice of paddling
location, I have a favorite – yet other kayaks I have owned (e.g. NDK Explorer) would come close.
I am not a highly
skilled paddler, nor adventuresome. I am a small person, ~140 pounds
and 5’ 5” in height ... continuing to shrink as appropriate for a
person born in 1940. Nowadays I only take day trips and accrue merely
200 nautical miles each season. I have a favorite kayak from the long
list of kayaks I have tried, not an overwhelming favorite, but
nonetheless a favorite. It is the Boreal Design Ellesmere (red deck rather than that in the picture above). I have
owned 2 of these over the years and currently have the Kevlar
version. Its specifications:
Bow, stern, and
day hatch
Skeg
17’ x 22”
Depth 12”
Weight 47
pounds
Keyhole cockpit
16” x 30”
This kayak is
similar to several of the kayaks I have owned. I am a bit small for
this kayak, but have padded it with minicell foam to fit well.
The Ellesmere is
reasonably fast and, since I am a slow paddler, it provides a nice
compromise. The semi-useful and crude Sound Rowers Classification for the Ellesmere is
9.0. It seems to want at least a bit of skeg, which is deployed via a
dial – which I rather like. Even with rolling practice, this kayak doesn’t seem to have leaks
via the hatches nor the skeg box. My first Ellesmere had a rather
intrusive skeg box, but this later version has a smaller skeg box
which doesn’t take up nearly as much space in the stern hatch.
Among my least
favorite kayaks, two stand out – a Sterling Ice Kap and a Boreal
Design Pakesso. To be fair, the Sterling was a demo model perhaps
prior to further development and ultimate release, but it was incredibly eager to weathercock. The
Pakesso was the rudder version, and tracked very poorly – poor even for a
short kayak.